MTG Confirms That There Are No Current Plans For Future Star Trek Sets

Star Trek will likely be a one-and-done Magic: The Gathering set.

Mark Rosewater announced during MagicCon Atlanta that there are no current plans fur any future Star Trek Universes Beyond sets. In a Blogatog post, Rosewater confirmed that, unlike the numerous Marvel or Middle-Earth sets, Star Trek is likely to be only the one set.

Question: 

"I get it now: just as MTG did a generic Marvels Super Hero set followed by the focused Marvel: Darkhold Destiny, so too MTG has done the generic Star Trek 60-year anniversary set and will surely follow it up with more focused Star Trek sets that need not be tied to specific TV series, but maybe on Star Trek eras or regions. You can have a Dominion War set, a Delta Quadrant set, a 23rd century set, etc. I look forward to seeing what's coming next year."

Rosewater:

"There are no current plans for future Star Trek sets. Also, Marvel Super Heroes wasn’t generic. It was what we called “Avengers plus”, it was a specific slice of the property."

While no reasons were given, there have been several hints in the past few weeks. First, overall popularity. While Marvel sets have sold well (sans Spider-Man), as have the two Middle Earth sets (The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit), Final Fantasy, and other UB sets, reception to Star Trek has been lukewarm. LGS sales and sales on secondary market sites has been low. Play boxes have fallen to nearly $100, with stores taking a big loss. Many have compared the set to what happened with Spider-Man last year. As Rosewater hinted at, Star Trek may also just not be a big enough universe for multiple sets, unlike other properties.

As for the fan view, many have noted that while there are many good cards in the set, many are tired of the space theme, with Trek coming on so close following Edge of Eternities. There have also been many issues with the value of boxes and, most surprisingly for Magic, complaints over the artwork.

Art for the set has been widely panned as ugly, inaccurate, or not being in the Magic style. It has been years since this kind of complaint has come up, and a sequel set would need to make a lot of liberties with the IP to make it more in the Magic style.

Overall, Magic always tends to plan around either popularity or inked deals when it comes to UB. And when mixed with player reaction and fans expressing their excitement with their wallets, it's clear to see why this may likely be the only Star Trek set to see print.