New Star Trek MTG Set Negatively Received by Community Say Local Game Stores

A recent poll by Wizards of the Coast of its Wizards Play Network stores has revealed that more than 80 percent say that the newly released Star Trek Universes Beyond set has been received negatively by their gaming communities, if not worse.

As of this story's writing, 61 percent of the WPN poll stated that Magic: The Gathering | Star Trek was received negatively by the stores' communities.  Another 22 percent stated that community response has been "very negative" with only a combined five percent stating that the set's reception was "positive" or better.

Reasons for the overwhelmingly negative reception to the Star Trek set seem to come from a number of directions including product delays, price, product fatigue, and an overall lack of player interest.

"Players that were interested are mad about the delays, and questioning why the Amazon and TCGplayer prices are so low and why I can't price match it (because they're literally under distro cost)," comments Rob Gootz, owner of Gootzy Gaming in Altoona, Pa.  "Collectors only want the commander decks and collector packs, but don't want to pay the higher universe beyond prices.  Poor player experience plus poor sales performance leaves this with no saving graces."

Gootz says it's the worst set he's ever been exposed to.  And he's not alone, it seems.

"Low single-digit turn-out at all events, low sales demand, and a lot of complaints that it’s a bad set that makes no sense as a crossover with Magic," says Ian Struckhoff, owner of The Fourth Place in Hanover, NH.  "A few Star Trek fans light up at the idea, and some new and casual players have been interested as a result, which is good, however, having a set that loses us money and event attendance, at the same time as we can’t get enough supply as a popular set, is a one-two punch to face."

Brian Williams, who works at Legacy Cards and Games in Victoria, Tex., is concerned for how smaller local game stores will be able to manage losses from the set's lack of sales and popularity.

"This is the kind of set that can kill a smaller lgs," he says.  "I didnt even sell my collectors boxes."

He doesn't think Star Trek being part of Magic: The Gathering's Universes Beyond product lineup is really the problem.

"The fact there are no chase style cards or much solid value is the problem," he adds.

Others are pointing to the fact that many Magic players are simply disconnected from the set due to its just not fitting in and meeting expectations of what should be considered a Magic: The Gathering set overall.

"The set is well designed within itself for sure [but] I believe it landed poorly overall due to sentiment of it not feeling like a true Magic set," comments Chance Mahon of Gamers XP Shreveport in Shreveport, La.  "The art direction and focus on the ultra realism and character focus lead to even greater disconnect for a lot of players."

He does point out one positive for the set as far as his store is concerned, though.

"I dont believe its all bad as we've had customers buy entire sets of cards for this when we rarely see that kind of behavior," he states.

Magic: The Gathering's next set, Nauctis: The Sunken Realm is scheduled to release Feb. 5, 2027.